McGoldrick and her husband George own Black Rock Country Club in Hingham. In addition to volunteering in the classroom alongside Cushing’s students, McGoldrick has served on Cushing’s Capital Campaign Steering Committee and the Development Committee. She chaired the Town Hall Building Committee in Cohasset from 2016 – 2018. Previously, McGoldrick was the Vice Chair of the Cohasset School Committee and from 2007-2013 served on the Board of the Cohasset Education Foundation as Grants Chair, Vice President, and President.